The Shadow Pup's Take:
No, they do not serve cornbread! This is NOT a meat and three. There is not even any fried chicken for the local trailer park trash! (Excuse me, I mean "manufactured housing dwellers.") At 130-A Commerce (across from Renaissance and in The Alley) it's "serious" Italian food with real garlic, olive oil, meatballs and pasta all served by people adorned with "serious" tattoos no doubt all over their wormy bodies. (Erase mental picture and move on....).
Some important tips from the Pup: First, unless you have large cahones do NOT even try to order the Calzones on the lunch menu 'cause there A'INT ANY! Why? Because they are "too much trouble" according to
Joe DiMaggio, Jr.--the guy in the NY Yankees hat at the counter and co-owner of the place. [Yes, he is a distant relation to "
The Yankee Clipper"] And--although sitting at the Chef's Counter is a treat--do NOT ask Joe: "What do you recommend?" because he will most likely retort, honestly, "Since I do not know you I do not have a clue what to recommend for you to eat." (He is, after all, a New Yorker). Do NOT be offended when he hands you your tab with the statement: "Now let me rip you off." Finally, do NOT ask him about all the tattoos on his body or why he likes to hire staff with tattoos. That's a story you do NOT really want to know....

Notice just the hint of tat on the right "gun."
Actually, DiMaggio has spent a lot of time working Italian restaurants boy and man. And here I mean Italian restaurants in Italy--which is the home of Italian food I think. DiMaggio is a key-man for this place to be a success. He has also written a pretty good
blog post about running restaurants that is funny and informative. It concerns me a little that he has also been named chef at restaurant in White Plains NY as of 2/16/2009. When he leaves Sa Zas' in the Gump, things could suffer. But keep in mind that Ken Register (Olive Room and Down the Street) is an owner so once Joe D gets them square, it should continue to be a quality place. So far, however, Joe-D has been in the kitchen every time I have eaten there. With him in charge the food is authentic and--for that reason--different from other Italian restaurants in the Gump. Take, for example, the use of marinara with extra virgin olive oil, chilies, reggiano cheese, fresh herbs and Sa Za GARLIC sticks for dipping. The stuffed hot peppers are truly a choice treat, with a blend of three meats, carrots, onion, fresh mozzarella, and cognac, all stuffed into Anaheim chilies, slow roasted and topped with more fresh mozzarella. Shipped in from Jersey are traditional pastas with such as angel hair served with Maine lobster meat, chopped shrimp and spinach in a chardonnay, exploded garlic and olive oil sauce. Another favorite pasta is the rigatoni Bolognese, a rich sauce made from carrots, celery, onion, veal, beef, pork, and cognac, then roasted for five hours before they hit it with cream, Carmelina's san marzano tomatoes and tossed with fresh herbs and rigatonis. Your Shadow Pup does not understand all this but likes the way it tastes. I do understand and like Pizza and it is very good at Sa Zas.

Joe-D doesn't wear a baseball hat or show his "tats" when with his "peeps" like Tony B.
That having been said, let's get down to the "serious" Italian food. I would say I have eaten at Sa Za's 7-8 times already and not once have I had a bad experience with the food. And, because I am such a loner like "sad girl," I never have to wait to get a seat at the Chef's Counter where I can pretend to know all the other loners sitting up there. However, if you are in a hurry and want a table for 6 you better gird for a wait because the place is still packed during normal lunch hours. The upside of this little problem is that it is packed because the food is way above average and, if you order smart, can be reasonably priced. One way to order smart is to get pizza by the slice during lunch or to order one of the "chopped" salads with smashed chicken. About $8 each and not too much food. Now the "meatball" sandwich is also a favorite in that category but is so large no one but--maybe Tojo--could eat the whole thing at one sitting.
Today, yours truly was joined by B-Diddy and B-Mack as we hoofed it in for lunch. The place is open for lunch 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. M-F. At 12 noon the place was packed. "Zeke" (the runaway "Buds" doorman) was there in his natty glasses and tats. There were no seats at the bar or Chef's Table and there was a large group of fatigue-clad Maxwell Country Club Members waiting in the lounge. After a 10-minute wait, however, three spots opened up at the bar (which is on the far side of the restaurant from the kitchen) and we bellied up where we were waited up by Jennifer the barmaid. B-Diddy ordered the stuffed peppers ($8) and B-Mack ordered pizza slices ($3 a pop). I ordered the sausage, onions and peppers sandwich ($9). It took a while so I popped another Valium and enjoyed the company and watched the flat screens. (Looks like Tiger/Cheetah's marriage is toast. The model is no longer wearing her wedding ring. She'll survive, just like we would survive the wait. But I, like Tojo, digress).
B-Diddy's dish looked really good but see his review below for the details. I have had the stuffed peppers before and they were good appetizers. My sandwich, however, was way too big and had no sauce at all on it. I mean, when they say sausage, peppers and onions they mean those things only. Why, I am lucky I got the bread. The bread is good but something was needed to hold the middle parts together. This did not stop me from eating every morsel, I should add. Couldn't tell if B-Mak liked her pizza or not. Regardless, the service was decent given the crowd and the fact that Jennifer had to fill all drink orders for bar patrons and the floor. (By the way, someone was hitting the wine bottle pretty hard. Hope it wasn't the Maxwell crowd or, if so, they aren't going to be on the trigger anytime this afternoon).
So take this, Cornbread Carp of the Trailer Park, with "Joltattin' Joe" at the helm Sa a's is really all it has been cracked up to be. You should make the effort to go and take your Valium for the wait like a normal person. Your humble pup would rate the place the best Italian restaurant in the Gump, or even in West Shorter and the land beyond the by-pass. At least, until Joe-D and Ken Register depart--which I hope is not soon--I rate Sa Za's at three of four paw prints (That's all I have). See B-Diddy's similar take below....
Bodiddly's Take:
Being the rabid Yankee fan I am, though he claims to be a distant cousin (here in Alabama you don’t get distant to a cousin unless it’s the 5th down the line), there is no way to convince me the proprietor of Sa Za’s, Joe Dimaggio, Jr., is related to THE Joe Dimaggio. But “Chef”, as he likes to be called, has hit a homerun with the food in the restaurant.
To digress a bit, while I enjoy the “banter” of a New Yorker and can “bust the chops” with the best of them, I must defend others who have gone to Sa Za’s and found “Chef” unaccommodating, rude and downright nasty (you can do this in New York where your customer base is 20 million, but in the Gump, say something to the wrong person(s) and you can find yourself out of the restaurant business fast---note the term “word of mouth”).
Back to the story, if you can, you need to ask to sit at the bar area where the food is prepared. “Chef” patrols the area and enjoys telling you how great he is, how great the food is and why you ought to be thankful he even let you come to his restaurant to eat. That aside, he is entertaining, makes helpful suggestions and will indulge you with stories about “his momma’s” recipes. But ask him how many homeruns his “cuz” hit, he has no idea.
Most of my eating at Sa Za’s has been done during lunch, but on occasion I have traveled with the Mrs. to partake of the “serious Italian food” and the draft Peroni and Chianti. When I sat down today at the bar-the real bar and not the one which Chef parades around-something kept sticking in my mind about the Gumpsters visit to the Green Papaya and the fact I couldn’t join Tojo and friends to celebrate his “coming out” of his hunger strike. Sticking with the mental thought of quantities of food and spiciness, I order the stuffed hot peppers and 2 glasses of water (I’m a big spender and why not go for the gusto and get 2 glasses instead of one). While the word “hot” has many different connotations to palates, to mine, it better mean my brow starts sweating when I smell the aroma. While this was not “hot” by my standards, it had a “kick” to it and the meat stuffing was really great. It is not one of the larger portions on the menu (try eating a sandwich in one sitting and you’ll see what I mean). With tax and tip, it was 11.00, so it fell close to the Gumpster Guidelines. I’d give it a three run homer by Dimaggio standards. Chef says it was at least a grand slam, but who listens to him anyway.