Being new to the group I wondered why LITG had not yet rated the place consistently rated No. 1 in The Montgomery Advertiser's "Peoples' Choice" award for: (1) Fried Chicken; (2) "Southern Cooking" and (3) Iced tea. After all, the place has benches outside because it usually is pretty crowed with...I must say it...some of the fatest people on earth (especially if you go early to beat the crowd). If you ever recoiled at the damage Waffle House has done to American waistlines, just sit alone at Martins around 11:30 a.m. and watch the parade of obesity squeeze through the front doors for their fried chicken fix. Please do not eat there alone because, if you do, your mind eventually wanders into people watching mode which, at Martins, invariably leads to the sin of smug, condescending judgments about the size of the clientele (at least if you are only mildly overweight after a Thanksgiving of splurging). Many had a former professional wrestler gut like Tojo Yamamoto (I've only seen him once from distance and he was still large from a distance). My mental victims, on the other hand, are probably thinking: "Why is that goofy guy wearing an ankle bracelet?" To which I say to myself: "NONE OF YOUR BEESWAX FATTY! And stop looking at my buttered muffins!"

One muffin missing. Two in mortal danger.
As sort of a poor joke on the obese, there is a LITE menu which features only one huge fried chicken breast along with two sides and three cornbread muffins with unlimited margerine. Obviously, I chose the LITE meal because it sounded better for me. Here, I have to say, the Davis Cafe & Lounge kicks Martin's butt all over the plate. Unlike the succulence of the Davis Cafe bird, the Martin's fowl was a little dry and had almost no seasoning. I also noted more bones than normal chickens are supposed to have. Perhaps my skills at dismembering the breast with a fork are to blame, but I was constantly chomping on bones--which is rarely fun with regard to eating yardbird. If this were a competition, the score would be Martins 1, Davis 1 after the entre.
Since the prices (about $8.50) are comparable, the tiebreaker would have to be dessert. Here, Martin's has a decided edge. Their fried pies are delicious and homemade and guaranteed to blow any diet, real or imagined.
The winner by a muffin top: Martin's Restaurant, 1796 Carter Hill Road. They are open 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. M-F and for Sunday Brunch. They serve dinner and things other than chicken (like chicken livers). They have a high local rating because....its an icon!! It has been around since 1940 and the service is quick and friendly. I would give it a 3.5 of 5 hot corn muffins soaked in real butter.


Cornbread Newboy hurt Tojo's feelings. Tojo have extra pounds to go against Iron Sheik and American Dream Dusty Rhodes. Tojo also have slow metabolism. Tojo invent Stomach Claw in 2nd grade when class bully in Osaka make fun of Tojo's husky school uniform. TOJO now have arch-nemesis... Cornbread Carp.
ReplyDeleteThat carp is a bottom feeder....
ReplyDeleteI will miss the smell of musty mutts in the lobby and the pet friendly buffet.
ReplyDeleteHe's the "Masked" Cornbread Carp. Beware....
ReplyDeleteAlthough I live within walking distance of Martin's, they won't see me there.
ReplyDeleteThe last time I was there, a waitress with a psychiatric disorder came rushing up, yammering away and re-arranging the table condiments. She rushed off, came back, took our order and when the food came, there was more shuffling of the table stuff.
Another time, a friend and I asked for gravy "on the side." The waitress thought a moment and said "I think I can do that."
She brought the food. EVERYTHING was smothered in gravy, and she brought extra bowls of gravy for us!
Don't expect me in there again.